Helping HEOP

PUBLISHED OCTOBER 26, 2007

For over 30 years, the Higher Education Opportunity Program, a partnership between New York State and New York colleges, has helped talented high school students from low-income backgrounds gain access to elite institutions like Columbia University and Barnard College. But three recent staff vacancies in the Barnard branch of the program present the school with a critical challenge: to build on the program's substantial successes without compromising the sense of community it has fostered. Barnard's administrators have, so far, been mindful of the students whom the program serves. They must ensure that their new hires reflect the same sensitivity to student concerns about the future direction of the program.

Admission to HEOP is competitive and, for those planning to enroll at Barnard, culminates in a six-week summer program prior to a student's first year. Admitted students receive testing, counseling, tutoring, and academic advising; financial aid is channeled through a combination of the New York State Tuition Assistance Program, Pell Grants, Stafford Loans, Federal Work Study, and special HEOP grants and stipends. For participating students, all of whom must be New York State residents, HEOP is more than the sum of its services. It is, they say, an on-campus sanctuary and a source of academic assistance and emotional support—a family away from home, and a direct channel for information and support amid college and university bureaucracy. Most of all, HEOP makes attendance at Barnard possible for those who might otherwise be unable to afford it.

Barnard's search for a director, assistant director, and counselor-adviser for the HEOP program makes this a sensitive time for students dependent on the services that the office provides. Interim director Saul Davis, Barnard College Dean Dorothy Denburg, and sophomore class dean Vivian Taylor have stepped in to guide students through this transition period. Barnard's deans deserve credit for meeting with HEOP students and keeping them informed about the process, for encouraging student input, and for answering questions in the HEOP office at designated times. Equally important, however, is that they hire replacements committed to HEOP's core purpose of affording disadvantaged students the opportunity to attend top-tier schools. HEOP students will, appropriately, participate in the interview process for the new director, and their views should carry significant weight.

The program director collaborates with Admissions, Financial Aid, the dean of studies, and members of the faculty for development of academic programs and heads a team of counselors, instructors, and assistants to meet HEOP program objectives. The director also represents HEOP and Barnard at outside conferences and community meetings. As such, it is imperative that Barnard select someone who appreciates what makes HEOP unique. More than merely a provisor of financial aid, the program is a one-stop shop for student needs and an essential source of support. To take it in a strictly academic direction, as some students fear will happen, would disserve the interests of its clients.

The new director will have much work to do, not least helping students become reoriented after the sudden decrease in program staffing. HEOP needs additional resources, as well, including an enlargement or renovation of the overcrowded office in which it is currently located. Since HEOP is predicated on personal connections between staffers and students, both the office and its personnel must be accessible and inviting. Above all, HEOP students want a director who understands the position of economically disadvantaged students at Barnard, who will look out for their interests, and who will preserve the supportive environment that HEOP has created.

Article Tools:

View Comments ( 13)

Post a Comment

It's not what works from them it is what works for us, but unfortunately the people who have created these chains of events does not think so. There were people who had problems with the way the HEOP office was ran, but the HEOP administration got things done effectively. There are several students here that feel betrayed by the Dean's office. Do they respect the students in HEOP? There are 4 open positions in the office that can answer that. I do understand that ALL the staff in HEOP left for different reasons, but it is very frustrating to have them gone because I do not trust the search committee’s judgment for picking the right Director for HEOP. Some people may ask "whats the big deal if were still getting the same benefits?" and for this person I say “you just don’t understand”. The people in HEOP were VERY relatable, they were easy to talk to about ANYTHING because they understood our lives beyond our academics. Socially HEOP was my sanctuary and now that they are gone there are so few people on this campus that come to mind that I can relate to and would feel comfortable even trying.
HEOP is not going to be the same, and I would be able to accept that only if the search committee respects the type of people that HEOP serves. Okay I am done now.

Is there a race factor that plays into this???? I doubt it. Although the presence of Minorities at Barnard and Columbia is lacking in EVERY ASPECT of this university… that would probably explain why Cindy has talked me out of leaving this school several times. LOL!

As a HEOP Barnard alumna, I am extremely disappointed with President Shapiro for allowing the circumstances that forced Francesca, Santa and Cynthia to leave HEOP. I am even more disappointed in Dean Shapiro, Dean Denburg and Dean Taylorfor allowing it to happen. As the first Barnard STEP student to enter Barnard, I am sadder still that Saul is even mixed up in all this, even if just as a stop gap measure. It is SCANDALOUS for me to think that after knowing these people for over two decades people cannot come to a table to hammer out their differences, especially with people who are clearly mission-driven and goal oriented as was the HEOP staff. The statistics and achievements of Barnard's HEOP classes speak for themselves.

The sugar coating and placating language being exposed is not based on integrity, honesty, or transparancy. These are core principles that any organization needs. Right now, it pains my heart to say that Barnard is sadly lacking and has fallen short of these principles.

This cannot stop here and it cannot stop now. The administration must and will be held accountable for its actions.

As an alum, this is isn't surprising. Barnard is simply racist; it doesn't matter if the people involved are black or white. Look at the history of the Pan African Studies Department. How many professors of color are tenured? Now HEOP, a program for mostly students of color—gets hostility instead of support and acknowledgement of its success. I won't be surprised it they stop the program even if it has existed for 40 years.
Question. How can you say financial aid is not going to be reduced when it obviously will be by eliminating the service of course fee payments?

I had a dream. I had a dream that at Barnard people would be judged by the content of their character, not the color of their skin. I had a dream that at Barnard I could trust adults. I had Dean Taylor as an adviser and trusted her. With the exchanges in the spectator I am disappointed not only in dean taylor but also the adults at Barnard who have participated in this. I am sad, sad, sad, sad, sad, sad, sad.

Not everyone who benefited from the Barnd HEOP program is against the overhaul. As a Banard HEOP alumna, I can say that not everyone loved the way Francesca and Santa ran the program - we took good with the bad and made the best of it.

However, I don't think anyone believes that this is a routine case of people leaving jobs and changing jobs. We need candid answers from Barnard so that we can all move on.

I don't think you understand the issue at hand. Why would one of the best programs in the state need an overhaul? Is this whole incident racially motivated since all the staff were either Latina or Black. Or is the one responsible for this "overhaul" mentally ill? As students, we are resilient and resourceful, but HEOP was the one place on campus I could be myself, and office where it was not stuffy or strict or "office like". Like on HEOP's website, one of the other students said " a sanctuary". Another student said HEOP stands for Helping Everyone Open their eyes to new Possibilities. The people in the HEOp office were bright, warm, sensitive, and helpful. They provided me with the support I needed. Something is not being said by the administration because why would people who care about us and work hard for us leave. I hope Barnard will look for qualities like these in the new people they hire.

Why were all the staff latino or black to begin with? Sup with that?

The administrator who is working on reconstructing Barnard HEOP is also black. As is the current HEOP chair. Please do not think that this is about racism. It really is not. I understand that you were friends with people in HEOP and they were nice, friendly and warm to you. But that is not the case for everyone. I am not saying this as a justification, I am just saying that the office was not so welcoming to everyone. There was definitely one person, who was amazing, I am sorry she decided to leave.

HEOP did not overhaul, people always leave jobs and other people come to replace them. If someone does a job differently from what the rules say, then those changes need to be reinstalled. That is all.

It is really not that big a deal, people leave jobs, change jobs, etc. Don't worry about it too much. The deans have been working very hard at filling the temporary gap. I think people are feeling too insecure for no reason. There are other resources there for you, other people to talk to, you don't need HEOP 24/7. Your financial aid is essentially not changing, only the course fees will not be available from next year, it's not that much money though. Please don't worry so much about this. It will be okay.

The state IS NOT aware or does not know the whole story.

The state is well aware of the situation at Barnard and is happy about the overhaul.

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • You may use <swf file="song.mp3"> to display Flash files inline
  • Allowed HTML tags: <!--pagebreak--><p><br><i><b><a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd><!--pagebreak-->
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

More information about formatting options

CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
Security question, designed to stop automated spam bots
-->