An Open Letter to the Sponsors of Al-Nakba Week

Dear Arab Students Association, Turath, and Filasteen,

For the last eight years, Columbia has witnessed a contentious debate between pro-Israel and pro-Palestinian students, filled with emotion and anger. Putting aside questions of right and wrong, there can be no doubt that the debate itself has been acrimonious. Accusations have been traded, extravagant events have been held, and controversial speakers have been given platforms. Like the conflict itself, our own antagonisms have no foreseeable end.

LionPAC would like to present an opportunity for Columbians to heal the division we have suffered over the Middle East conflict. If we are prudent, responsible, sensitive, and truly willing to engage in the steps necessary to build trust, we can begin to bridge gaps, to meet each other as people, and to recognize that we all have legitimate points.

To enter such discussions, we must recognize that both Israelis and Palestinians have suffered. Remembering the past is important—but letting the past interfere with reality and block any prospect for the future is reckless. To achieve a solution, we must accept that compromise is necessary. LionPAC recognizes the Palestinian right to self-determination, and supports the creation of a Palestinian state. We only ask that you do the same for the Jewish right to self-determination.

The dialogue we propose requires diligent thought and planning, down to the smallest details. We do not offer this as a ploy or a political trick. We fully intend for this to take place, if you are willing to join us. As a first step, we propose a private meeting among representatives of our organizations to initiate discussions and talk about moving forward. While we fully understand the potential for failure, we believe that the time has come to challenge ourselves and search for solutions. Next semester we look forward to working together.

Our hand is extended. Will you meet us?

Jacob Shapiro

The author, a former Spectator News writer and current Sports writer, is a dual degree at the School of General Studies and List College, majoring in history and Jewish law, respectively. He is the president of LionPAC.